Skip to main content
Custom Home Building Tips

What an HOA Architectural Review Covers Before You Build or Renovate in the Charlotte Area

Eric Brown
What an HOA Architectural Review Covers Before You Build or Renovate in the Charlotte Area

An HOA architectural review for a Charlotte custom home is a private review under the recorded declaration, not a building permit. Chapter 47F of the North Carolina General Statutes, the Planned Community Act, applies to planned communities created in this State, and it does not apply to planned communities or lots located outside this State [1]. The chapter does not publish a list of drawings or material notes for that private review [2]. It also leaves the building code in place, so the covenant review and the permit remain different acts [3].

Is the architectural review the same act as the building permit?

No. A covenant decision and a building permit answer different questions.

G.S. 47F-1-106 says a zoning, subdivision, or building code may not prohibit a planned community, or impose a requirement it would not impose on a substantially similar development under another form of ownership. Otherwise, no provision of Chapter 47F invalidates or modifies any zoning, subdivision, or building code, or any other real estate use law [3].

The permit duty is separate. G.S. 160D-1110(a) says that, except as subsection (c) and one commercial provision allow, no person shall start construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, movement, removal, or demolition of a building, or the plumbing, heating or cooling, and electrical work that section describes, without the permits the North Carolina State Building Code and other applicable laws require [4]. Some replacements are excepted, including certain water-heater and lighting-fixture replacements in a one- or two-family dwelling when the section's conditions are met [4]. A building permit has to be in writing and has to say the work will comply with the State Building Code and other applicable state and local laws [4].

Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement states that issuing building, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical permits under that statute is one of its primary jobs, including residential permits for new construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, movement, removal, or demolition, and for electrical, mechanical, and plumbing work on one- and two-family dwellings and townhomes [5]. A committee created by a declaration is not that office. A code-compliant plan can still break a covenant, and a covenant-compliant plan can still be work that cannot start until the permits are in hand [3][4].

What drawings and material notes does the law require the committee to see?

The statute requires no statewide set of drawings or material notes.

The compiled text of Chapter 47F does not use the word architectural, and it does not require elevations, a finish schedule, or material notes [2]. Unless the articles or the declaration expressly provide to the contrary, G.S. 47F-3-102 lets the association adopt bylaws and rules, and lets it regulate the use, maintenance, repair, replacement, and modification of common elements [6]. Common elements are real estate the association owns or leases inside the community, other than a lot [7]. That is not a statutory power to approve the finishes inside a house. The same section allows reasonable fines for violations of the declaration, bylaws, and rules, after notice and an opportunity to be heard, unless the articles or the declaration say otherwise [6]. A fine enforces a restriction that already exists. It does not list drawings.

A declaration is any instrument, however titled, that creates a planned community, plus amendments [7]. It must be executed like a deed and recorded in every county where any part of the community lies [8]. To the extent they fit the chapter, the declaration, bylaws, and articles are enforceable by their terms, and if the declaration and the bylaws conflict, the declaration prevails unless the declaration is what conflicts with the chapter [9]. Except where a section allows it, the declaration and bylaws may not vary the chapter [10]. Rules under G.S. 47F-3-102(1) are available only if the articles and the declaration have not taken that power away [6]. The owner has to read that community's declaration, its amendments, and any guidelines the declaration authorizes. A generic checklist does not decide it.

Does every interior renovation need the association's approval?

No. Chapter 47F does not say that.

Except as the declaration provides, the lot owner maintains his lot and the improvements on it, and the association maintains the common elements [11]. That maintenance duty is not a design review of interior work. If the recorded document covers the change, it is enforceable to the extent it stays consistent with the chapter [9]. The statute does not say that every renovation, interior or otherwise, needs the association's approval.

Permit law draws a different line. G.S. 160D-1110(c) says no permit issued under Article 9 of Chapter 143 is required for work costing $40,000 or less in a single-family residence, farm building, or commercial building, when the work follows the current State Building Code, unless the work is a kind the subsection lists [4]. The list includes load-bearing work, with an exception for replacing windows, doors, exterior siding, or porch and deck pickets, railings, stair treads, and decking when the rest of the subsection is met. It includes a plumbing redesign, except replacements that do not change size or capacity. It includes added or redesigned heating, air-conditioning, or electrical work, other than like-kind replacement of electrical devices and lighting fixtures. It includes materials the code forbids, added roofing as distinct from replacement, and changes the North Carolina Fire Code covers [4]. Mecklenburg's page states its own $40,000 summary, and the wording is not identical to the statute, so the statute is the list I use [5]. The dollar figure is a permit threshold, not a covenant threshold [4].

Which lots does Chapter 47F cover, including a lot at Lake Wylie?

It covers planned communities in North Carolina, with stated exceptions, and not a lot outside the state.

The chapter applies to planned communities created in this State on or after January 1, 1999, except as G.S. 47F-1-102 provides, and it does not apply to planned communities or lots located outside this State [1]. The Census Bureau's 2025 Gazetteer of places, in the South Carolina file, lists Lake Wylie CDP [12]. A lot in that place is outside Chapter 47F. I am not describing South Carolina association law, and a permit there is not a Mecklenburg permit. The lake's name is also used for other lots. The name does not matter. The statute asks whether the lot is in this State [1].

A planned community is real estate where owning a lot expressly obligates the owner, by a declaration, to pay taxes, insurance, or other expenses for other lots or other real estate the declaration describes. A condominium or a cooperative is not itself a planned community under that definition, though it may sit inside one, and a leasehold under 20 years, counting renewals, is not ownership of a lot for the definition [7]. A neighborhood name alone does not create the payment duty.

On or after January 1, 1999, the chapter also skips a community of no more than 20 lots, counting lots development rights may still add, and a community limited to nonresidential lots, unless the declaration opts in [1]. Before that date, only a listed group of sections applies, unless the articles or the declaration say otherwise. The group includes G.S. 47F-3-102(1) through (6) and (11) through (17), upkeep under G.S. 47F-3-107(a) through (c), the fine procedure, and the meeting, assessment, lien, and records sections the statute names. They apply only to events on or after January 1, 1999, and they do not invalidate an existing declaration, bylaws, or plats and plans [1]. An older community can take the whole chapter by an amendment of at least 67 percent of the votes, or any smaller majority the declaration specifies [1].

Where does the submittal list come from if the statute will not write one?

From that declaration, its amendments, and guidelines the declaration authorizes.

Start with the recorded instrument and its amendments [8][7]. Plats and plans filed with it belong in the same reading. The pre-1999 rule does not cancel them, and a declarant may have reserved the right to finish improvements shown on them [1][7]. Those sheets describe the original community. They are not a form for this year's house. If a review exists, the declaration is what names the reviewer, the submittal, and the standard.

Chapter 47F adds no response deadline for that review [2]. Time periods in the chapter concern other subjects, including meetings, budgets, unpaid assessments, and insurance notices. I will not relabel one of them as an approval clock, and silence from a committee is not an approval under the statute. Any response time has to be a term of that declaration [9]. A rule adopted under G.S. 47F-3-102(1) can spell out a procedure only if the articles and the declaration have not said otherwise [6]. If the bylaws and the declaration conflict, the declaration prevails unless the declaration is what conflicts with the chapter [9].

What does the county ask to see, and why is that a different package?

Mecklenburg County reviews project plans for the building code, not for the covenants.

If a local government chooses to review residential plans, G.S. 160D-1110(b) requires the initial building-permit review within 15 business days of submission [4]. If that review is not done within 20 business days, the government shall refund 10 percent of the total permit application fee for each business day of delay, for not more than 10 business days [4]. The same subsection does not force every local government to review residential plans. It also bars a required engineer or architect seal on one- and two-family plans unless the State Building Code requires one, and it bars a permit unless the plans and specifications give the author's name and address [4]. A declaration may still ask for a seal. That county limit does not edit the covenants [3].

Mecklenburg checks that plans and supporting materials follow the North Carolina Building Code [13]. Residential review there covers new construction, remodels, and additions on single-family, two-family, or townhouse buildings of three stories or fewer. For a custom-built project that needs plan review, the page describes an application, zoning and erosion forms, and the project plans [14]. The scope includes new one- and two-family houses, an enclosed addition that grows the footprint by 100 square feet or more (decks and screen porches are outside that trigger), an added story, and a renovation over $175,000 that includes structural work, among other cases on the page [14]. Those are code-review triggers. They are not the association's list, and the county's supporting materials are not a set of finish samples. This description is Mecklenburg's. Another North Carolina county can follow the same statute and run a different desk [4]. A South Carolina lot is outside both [1][12].

What do the statute's fines have to do with a design review?

They are a hearing about a violation, not a deadline for approving drawings.

Unless the articles or the declaration provide otherwise, the association may, after notice and a chance to be heard, fine an owner or suspend privileges other than access to the lot for a violation of the declaration, bylaws, or rules [6]. If the declaration sets no procedure, G.S. 47F-3-107.1 requires a hearing before the board or a panel of members who are not officers and not on the board. The owner gets notice of the charge, a chance to be heard and to present evidence, and notice of the decision [15].

A fine, if one is imposed, may not exceed $100 for the violation and, without another hearing, for each day more than five days after the decision that the violation continues [15]. A panel decision may be appealed to the full board by written notice delivered within 15 days, and the board may affirm, vacate, or modify it [15]. That cap and those days apply to fines when the declaration is silent on procedure. They are not a clock for approving a house or a renovation. Chapter 47F states no architectural-review deadline [2].

Practical takeaways

  • The recorded declaration and its amendments control the private review. Chapter 47F has no drawing list and no committee deadline [2][7][8].
  • A permit under G.S. 160D-1110 is a separate act. Chapter 47F does not modify the building code [3][4].
  • Not every interior change needs association approval. Lot repair stays with the owner unless the declaration says otherwise [11].
  • The chapter covers North Carolina planned communities, with a no-more-than-20-lot exception, a nonresidential exception, and a shorter list for communities created before January 1, 1999. It does not cover a lot in the Lake Wylie place in the South Carolina gazetteer [1][12].
  • The $40,000 figure in G.S. 160D-1110(c) is a permit threshold with statutory exceptions, not a covenant rule [4].
  • If the declaration is silent, the hearing and the $100 cap in G.S. 47F-3-107.1 concern a violation that has occurred, not a design deadline [15].

How we can help

We are a building company. We build custom homes on an owner's lot, and we also renovate houses and add to them. When a declaration is in the chain of title, it belongs in the conversation before drawings are treated as final, next to the permit the code requires. If you want to talk through a lot you already own, start on our build on your lot page.

Citations

  1. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-1-102" (2022)
  2. North Carolina General Assembly, "Chapter 47F" (2026)
  3. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-1-106" (1998)
  4. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 160D-1110" (2024)
  5. Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement, "Permitting" (2026)
  6. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-3-102" (2020)
  7. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-1-103" (2014)
  8. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-2-101" (2012)
  9. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-2-103" (2013)
  10. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-1-104" (2013)
  11. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-3-107" (2013)
  12. U.S. Census Bureau, "2025 Gazetteer Places, South Carolina" (2025)
  13. Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement, "Plan Review" (2026)
  14. Mecklenburg County Code Enforcement, "Residential Plan Review" (2026)
  15. North Carolina General Assembly, "G.S. 47F-3-107.1" (2005)